Real Time with Bill Maher last week had an interesting moment in which P.J. O’Rourke and San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom were lamenting the loss of famous daily papers in big cities like the San Francisco Chronicle and the Rocky Mountain News. After they were predictably deriding blogs for ruining newspapers but not reporting any news for themselves, panelist Alan Cumming said that the death of newspapers was “just part of the progression of technology,” and that eventually blogs will hire their own news staff to start ‘creating’ the news where papers left off. The other panelists’ reaction could best be described as incredulous.
But what most people who find it fashionable to criticize new media never realize is that this has already happened. Josh Marshall’s Talking Points Memo employs real, live reporters, as does Politico, which was recently described in a barely cutting edge magazine article as “the first internet newspaper.”
But Talking Points Memo, Politico, and Huffington Post, which doesn’t hide their pride at being a hybrid blog/newspaper, all have staffs, and they all create their own news in addition to linking widely to other sources. This is the future of big ticket journalism, and its critics are soon reaching the point where they’re going to have to stop derisively calling anything without a print issue counterpart a “blog.” We’re beyond that now.
Yes, local news will suffer. But Denver still has the Denver Post, and even if the Chronicle goes under, San Francisco will not be long without a daily paper. In a city of millions, do you really think someone is going to pass up the opportunity to open a daily or weekly local newspaper operation?
Papers will be smaller, almost entirely local news-based, and perhaps published less frequently than daily. And they will employ a newsroom staff of no more than 10 or 20 people, with maybe a dozen more writing part time, even in big city papers. This is a business model which is completely sustainable. And it involves significantly fewer people than most papers are used to employing, but that’s just because they haven’t yet been willing to ask the most obvious question of all:
How many more do you really need?


Recent Comments